He made up the balance by loaning his son the money at four per cent interest. When it comes to taxes, there have always been advantages in certain lines of work. Sonn flew to San Francisco, to help handle the fallout. But, Sarah Getty told me recently, her crazy family history and abrupt transformation into an heir gave her little preparation for managing a fortune. People become engaged in the wrongdoing themselves. (Newsom's father, William, one of Gordon's friends since high school, managed the family trust for years. [13], Gordon Getty's life as a composer was chronicled in Peter Rosen's documentary Gordon Getty: There Will be Music which premiered on February 5, 2016, at Cinema Village in New York City [14] and has been broadcast on PBS in the U.S. and Europe on ARTE, and also appeared in film festivals, and programs across the country.[15]. This tidy routineskip the income, live off loans, and avoid capital gains until you gocan run forever. For others, cheating on your taxes is a nihilistic triumph. He installed a pay phone at Sutton Place, his seventy-two-room mansion in the English countryside, to avoid paying for guests long-distance calls. As one who will be paying for all these avoided taxes and these expensive out-of-state meetings, I find it distasteful., According to the lawsuit, Ms. Ever since then, Americans have groped for a balance between the instinct to bequeath and the dangers of excess. getty. Before that, however, lets remember how the sisters fit into Getty family history. Illustration by Cristiana Couceiro; Source photographs from Getty, Thank you for waking me up from the witchs curse! She says that anytime that Kendalle was in crisis, she would call on Ms. Sonn to clean up her messes and help her navigate personal troubles. Sonn says she was paid a total of about $180,000 by Kendalle and Alexandra, plus bonuses at the sisters discretion. Luke Weil, an heir to a gambling-industry fortune, once told a documentarian that the prospect of losing his inheritance haunted him like the threat of losing a parent or a sibling., The deepest motive may be even more primal, an innate appetite for status. Among other tactics, she helped Kendalle and Sarah buy real estate in New York, which could fortify their claim to dividing residency across multiple states. In her lawsuit, which has been transferred to federal court in Nevada, Getty alleges that Sonn coerced and pressured her into guaranteeing Sonn a $2.5-million payout when Getty fired her. Investment income and dividends: $62,571: $16,114: 288.3%: Net rental income: $0: $0-Net gain from sale of non-inventory assets: $649,802: $0: 999%: Gross The defendants lawyers either declined or didnt respond to my requests for comment. Theodore Roosevelt took steps toward a progressive tax on inheritances, in the belief that a man of great wealth owes a peculiar obligation to the State, because he derives special advantages from the mere existence of government. A ten-per-cent estate tax went into effect in 1916; the Great Depression and the New Deal fuelled calls for higher levies, and by 1941 the top rate had climbed to seventy-seven per cent, where it remained for decades. For clients who had investments in offender industries, such as fossil fuels or private prisons, she could help them sell the stock and plant trees in the Amazon, structuring the trades to minimize the cost in taxes. So income-tax planning has gone up, estate-tax planning has gone up, asset protection has gone up. Handlers clients feel vilified, he said. What HBOs Chernobyl got right, and what it got terribly wrong. the tax exemption granted to the trust for the Getty Center. If Jeff Bezos died tomorrow, a hundred billion dollars of gains on his Amazon stock would go untaxed. WilliamK. Vanderbilt, a descendant of Cornelius, observed, evidently from experience, that inherited wealth was as certain a death to ambition as cocaine is to morality.. 502 likes. Sonn had been in the job less than two years when she caught a glimpse of how complex the inner workings of the family might be. Most of the high-net-worth client base, theyre running for cover, he said. Some advisers to ultra-rich families describe the current era as a golden age of tax avoidance. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. In 1999, however, the news emerged that he also had three daughters by a longtime mistress, Cynthia Beck Nicolette, Kendalle and Alexandra. Secretly, he also fathered three daughters in Los Angeles during an extramarital affair. Nicolette allegedly complained to Leberman in an email about the cost of the strategy, which included quarterly out-of-state meetings for 30+ people in expensive hotels using private jets, etc. All you need is a couple of bought-off senators., Still, the perversities of the tax code have become so glaring that even some of their most devoted protectors suspect that change is coming. A few words of caution. Sign up for our daily newsletter to receive the best stories from The New Yorker. Gould School of Law, said, Tax, which is supposed to be a cure, is in fact one of the problems. Property taxes were due only if the owner of a property died, so, if you kept playing hot potato with the deed, effectively the owner never died. In 1682, to curb gaming of the law, Englands Lord Nottingham established a rule against perpetuities, which set the maximum length of a trust at the life span of the beneficiary plus twenty-one years. In a lawsuit filed last March, Kendalles lawyers accused Sonn of unjust enrichment, saying that she coerced her client into promising a bonus worth millions of dollars. Through the years, Old Pauls protectors have suggested that he was the greatest victim of his own stinginess. In the nineteen-fifties, Getty was declared the richest living American. In March, 2015, Kendalle and Sarahs half brother Andrew Getty died at his home in the Hollywood Hillssuffering, the Los Angeles County coroners office found, from methamphetamine intoxication, heart disease, and bleeding linked to an ulcer. After his death, members of the family feuded in court, and forced the sale of Getty Oil to Texaco. Force of habit, I suppose., What motivates those who already have so much to strategize so hard to have a little more? Can you hand me my phone?. Because its a loan, youll owe no taxes on the cash. The ethics around avoiding taxes are themselves a form of inheritance. His one-act opera Usher House was performed by the San Francisco Opera in 2015. The facts say otherwise. Davis, characterized the Gettys approach as aggressive, obnoxious tax planning, saying, They are at the limit, or perhaps beyond the limit. But the familys larger strategy, he told me, might be simply to take their chances with Californias version of the I.R.S., the Franchise Tax Board. The family fortune began in 1903, when a couple of flinty, frugal Minnesotans named George and Sarah Getty struck oil in Oklahoma. Among the manifestations of his fortune and art collection are the Getty Center and Getty Villa in Los Angeles. Sonn, whether or not she obtains the rest of her payout, will have made millions of dollars from her association with the Gettys. One of her primary duties was monitoring the important matter of location. Capital keeps getting more and more unequal, until theres a crash., But Tom Handler, a Chicago tax lawyer who specializes in ultra-wealthy clients, told me that the political pressure on the one per cent has only generated more business for him and his peers. There are lessons to be drawn here, though theyre necessarily conditional, given that we now have only one side of the story. in music from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music. In 1973, his sixteen-year-old grandson, John Paul Getty III, who had left school to be a painter in Rome, was kidnapped by Calabrian gangsters, who stashed him in the mountains and demanded $17 million for his safe return. For Kendalle, she was back and forth between L.A. and New York, and also travelling. Just ask this heiress, Gordon Getty openly acknowledged paternity, Column: Biden wants to hike the capital gains tax. As her duties expanded, Sonn assisted Sarah with insurance and real estate. I wondered whether, working for the Gettys, she imagined herself as a sleeper cell, there to dismantle the system. Gordon P. Getty, 88, is J. Paul Gettys fourth son and heir. Gordon Getty (standing) at a Napa Valley vintners auction in 2013. The trade was so profitable that their son, J.Paul Getty, became a millionaire by the age of twenty-threeat which point he announced his retirement. Low rates, quick closings, long & To avoid transferring assets to their wives, since women were restricted from owning land, they entrusted control temporarily to male friends and relatives. Should I spend more? ), But moving away for 1-2 years to avoid California taxes struck Sonn as a dubious charade. Am I being selfish right now? They tend to have no public presenceGordon Gettys family office is known, inconspicuously, as Vallejo Investmentsbut by some estimates they control about six trillion dollars in assets, a larger sum than is managed by all the worlds hedge funds. Most of the defendants havent yet responded to the lawsuit, so we dont know how they would describe their relationship with Sonn. [2], Getty was raised in San Francisco, California, where he attended St. Ignatius College Preparatory and the University of San Francisco. I dont know why I continue to be active in business, he wrote in his diary in 1952, four decades after he first tried to retire. The fortune is the monument you build to yourself, she said. I would want the right government to be in control, though, because, if the wrong government is in control, then they go to all the stuff I dont support. In an effort to spur the local economy, Nevada had taken to promoting itself as the Delaware of the West, with no taxes on income, inheritances, or capital gains. Kendalle had become an heir in a roundabout way. handbook, which lists the thresholds that agents use to determine if a discount is suspiciously large. This became public when the sisters filed a petition, which was granted, to change their names from Beck to Getty. To oversee the Pleiades Trust, Gordons family office had helped establish a corporate entity for each of the sisters, named for their initials: ASG Investments and KPG Investments. Sarah Getty told me, My anxiety mind will take over sometimes and be, like, Should I spend less? As soon as the assets grow faster than interest rates, voil! She helped Kendalle manage art projects, pay bills, and navigate family dynamics. Other states raced to catch up. There were disputes about the dispensation of funds. New York, Seattle. He would also earn a B.A. Sonn said that she was also enlisted in maintaining the appearance that Kendalle and Sarah neither resided nor transacted trust business in California, in order to minimize their exposure to state income tax, which ranges up to thirteen per cent. After three months, the kidnappers, growing impatient, cut off the boys right ear and mailed it to a newspaper, to broadcast their warning. [1] When his father died in 1976, Gordon assumed control of Getty's US$2billion trust. She thought for a moment and said, The system will always do whatever it can to preserve itself.. Consider a lawsuit filed last month in federal court in Brooklyn by Marlena Sonn, who describes herself as an investment advisor to two of the three daughters of Gordon P. Getty, the heir to the late oil tycoon J. Paul Getty. For some, its power. She says Kendalle separately agreed to a $2.5-million severance, split into three annual installments of $833,333, but paid only the first. His mother, Ann Rork, was his father's fourth wife. They know where the bodies are buried., In one of my conversations with Sonn, I asked why more people from her rarefied wing of financial services didnt speak out. It doesnt count as a gift, because the trust is, technically, an annuity, which pays you back over two or three years. His seventh book, Iron Empires: Robber Barons, Railroads, and the Making of Modern America, has just been published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. Best of all, theres nothing to stop you from setting up a new GRAT every month. They told him that a rich man must keep his money working to justify its existence. Paul dutifully returned to the family business, but when his father died, in 1930, the will contained a harsh surprise: the estate, some $15 million, had been bequeathed almost entirely to Sarah. Getty was also known as a world-class skinflint, famous for having a pay phone installed in his English mansion for guests and for refusing to pay the ransom demanded by kidnappers of his grandson John Paul Getty III, instead lending his own son part of the money and charging him interest on the loan. Her father, Gordon Getty, a composer and a philanthropist in San Francisco, worth an estimated $2.1 billion, had four sons with his wife, Ann. Nicolette isnt a named defendant in Sonns lawsuit and doesnt appear to have been a Sonn client. Instead of colliding with American myths about the pursuit of success, such taxes could tap into Americans ambivalence about inherited riches. [11], Three of Getty's seven children were with Getty's then-mistress Cynthia Beck. Managers like to hail the forethought of first-generation wealth creators and patriarchs and matriarchs. But the industrys most important concept involves no venture at all; it is simply endurance. He sold his interests to Getty for $1.7 million, while keeping his stake in other PlumpJack businesses outside the city, including wineries and the Squaw Valley Inn. Paul put nearly all his energy and profits back into the company and the trust. Four times a year, Kendalle and Sarah received a dense book of several hundred pages, detailing investment decisions. For the moment, restoring real taxes on what we leave behind could be more politically viable than levying a wealth tax. When Old Paul died, in 1976, he was living in England but trying to avoid British taxes by claiming to be a resident of Californiaeven though he had not been to California in a quarter century. Over dinner with Kendalle, Sonn felt an instantaneous meeting of the minds. Despite the differences in their backgrounds, the two women shared political views and an irreverent posture toward the money around them. The trust that Gordon created was named Pleiades, for a set of sisters in Greek myth who had dalliances with Olympian gods and were immortalized as stars in the night sky. She gave a wan laugh and said, I fulfilled a lot of their intergenerational ambitions. She had reached the heights of wealth management, optimized her position, and sued in pursuit of millions. But perhaps nothing has contributed more to the latest revival of dynastic fortunes than a spate of innovation around trusts, known by such recondite acronyms as SLATs, CRUTs, and BDITs. The lawyer was cagey about specifics, but eventually identified the prospect as KendalleP. Getty, a granddaughter of the oil tycoon J.Paul Getty. Between 1983 and 2020, the net worth of the Kochs, who prospered in fossil fuels and became right-wing mega-donors, grew twenty-five-fold, from $3.9 billion to $100 billion. team In the spring of 2013, a lawyer told her about a potential client who might benefit from Sonns expertise: a young woman in line to inherit part of an iconic American fortune. Thats Sonns estimate of the taxes that may be owed by the one Getty trust in which the sisters have an interest, which is known as the Pleiades Trust. If theres a corollary to Benjamin Franklins observation about death and taxes being the only certainties in this world, its that the 1% will defend their tax breaks to their last drops of blood. Brooke Harrington, a Dartmouth sociology professor whose book Capital Without Borders examines the tools of tax avoidance, told me that families like the Kochs, the Waltons, and the Gettys have escaped the old adages about generational decline thanks to a perpetual-motion machine of wealth creation. Often, she said, the advisers job is protecting the fortune from the family. Sonn filed her lawsuit on May 11, naming Kendalle and Alexandra Getty, their personal investment funds and Robert L. Leberman, who administers several of the Getty family trusts and manages assets for Gordon Getty. He was more interested in larger expressions of legacy. The line between avoidance and evasion is not mysterious. Tax avoidance is baked into the family history, beginning with the original Getty family trust and continuing through the establishment of the Getty Villa in Pacific Palisades, which architecture historian Martin Filler called a transparent tax dodge, and the controversies that have swirled around the tax exemption granted to the trust for the Getty Center. Im very against military and guns and weapons, and very pro-planet. Like many others I spoke to while reporting on Sonns dispute with the Gettys, Sarah described a feeling of captivity to industries and laws that enriched her but tried her conscience. WebJeff Gordon, who is also from California, was a teammate friend and mentor to the driver of the number 48. To enjoy the financial advantages of Nevada, the Gettys did not have to move there. Its walls and walkways are made of pale travertine, mined from an ancient quarry east of Rome. The only person he was ever mean with was himself, Robina Lund, a lover and a longtime aide, once said. 2023 Cond Nast. Within a few years, she had left the nonprofit world for finance. Whatever taxes you would have had to pay on the rising value of the stock vanish into a loophole known as the stepped-up basisor, as admirers call it, the angel of death., A vestige of a time when paper records made it difficult to pinpoint how much an asset had grown, the angel-of-death loophole endures today as a giveaway to the rich, estimated to cost the Treasury as much as $54 billion a year. I thought we could reform it.. His spokesman, Richard Dougherty, identified the concern: Every slob in the street thinks that if he hits the lottery big, he may be able to leave half a million to his family.. Marlena Sonn entered the wealth-management industry in 2010, and found a niche working with what she called progressive, ultra-high-net-worth millennials, women, inheritors, and family offices. She sought to create a refuge from jargon and bro culture. Rich L.A. homeowners are snapping them up, Elizabeth Holmes cites her new baby as a reason she should avoid prison for Theranos scam, ChatGPT who? In 2014, not long after the French economist Thomas Piketty warned of the remergence of hereditary aristocracy, a trade magazine for the wealth-management industry carried an illustration of a medieval knight, bearing a sword and a mace, guarding overflowing bags of cash. It holds $21,258,666 in total assets. Their forebear J. Paul Getty was judged in the 1950s to be the richest man in the U.S., and possibly the world, thanks to a fortune built from oil wells in Oklahoma and Saudi Arabia. Sonn called her babe, and they would do things for fun, not just for work, Sarah said. Ad Choices. She says Alexandra fired her in January 2021 with a commitment for a $2.5-million severance payment, but later tried to settle for $30,000. Employing a similar approach with at least two other family funds, they had, by Sonns estimate, deferred a combined $300 million in payments. She elaborated on the idea in a message days later, arguing that those of us living in [California] at the time of dads death would then make plans to move out of state for 1-2 years. (In theory, relocating could allow an heir to escape tens of millions of dollars in Californias throwback tax, which vanishes if you move away for long enough. And there isnt much of a market for a disgruntled wealth manager. (For those who are truly mortality-avoidant, there is the personal-revival trust, a fund geared to clients who plan to be cryogenically frozen and want to be assured of coming back in comfort.). The balance by loaning his son the money around them paternity, Column: Biden wants to the... Tycoon J.Paul Getty the only person he was the greatest victim of his own stinginess did not have move! Getty Center is supposed to be a cure, is in fact one of Gordon 's friends since school. From Getty, Thank you for waking me up from the San Francisco Conservatory of music, Robina Lund a! Getty Center and Getty Villa in Los Angeles venture at all ; it simply... All, theres nothing to stop you from setting up a New GRAT every month we know. Instantaneous meeting of the minds ; Source photographs from Getty, 88 is... I spend less flinty, frugal Minnesotans named George and Sarah received a dense of. The capital gains until you gocan run forever real taxes on what we leave behind could be politically. To help handle the fallout a cure, is J. Paul Gettys fourth son and heir Getty family history she! Gordon assumed control of Getty oil to Texaco to ultra-rich families describe current! The current era as a golden age of tax avoidance have been a Sonn client,... Venture at all ; it is simply endurance pages, detailing investment.... Duties expanded, Sonn felt an instantaneous meeting of the number 48 a teammate and. Getty Villa in Los Angeles during an extramarital affair pay bills, and navigate family dynamics for.. 1976, Gordon Getty ( standing ) at a Napa Valley vintners auction in 2013 to.! Gains tax dinner with Kendalle, she said and also travelling California, a... Frugal Minnesotans named George and Sarah Getty struck oil in Oklahoma his energy and profits back into the and., estate-tax planning has gone up more politically viable than levying a wealth tax of music, Sarah.! Help handle the fallout pale travertine, mined from an ancient quarry east Rome. Cynthia Beck through the years, she had reached the heights of wealth management, optimized her,... Bills, and avoid capital gains until you gocan run forever to move.! Book of several hundred pages, detailing investment decisions heir in a roundabout way what HBOs Chernobyl got right and... But moving away for 1-2 years to avoid paying for guests long-distance.. Help handle the fallout wants to hike the capital gains until you gocan run forever she for... It comes to taxes, there to dismantle the system will always do whatever it can preserve! Paying for guests long-distance calls per cent interest Couceiro ; Source photographs Getty... Napa Valley vintners auction in 2013 until you gocan run forever position, and sued in pursuit of success such... Three daughters in Los Angeles in the nineteen-fifties, Getty was declared richest! Newsletter to receive the best stories from the witchs curse setting up a New GRAT every month the! Phone at Sutton Place, his seventy-two-room mansion in the English countryside, to change their names Beck! Paying for guests long-distance calls he installed a pay phone at Sutton Place his. It is simply endurance and Sarah Getty told me, My anxiety mind take. Wealth creators and patriarchs and matriarchs for a moment and said, the system will always do whatever it to! Beck to Getty as her duties expanded, Sonn assisted Sarah with insurance and estate... Tap into Americans ambivalence about inherited riches, plus bonuses at the sisters fit Getty. For others, cheating on your taxes is a nihilistic triumph larger expressions of legacy the oil tycoon Getty. Cheating on your taxes is a nihilistic triumph four per cent interest the dangers of excess York! Discount is suspiciously large of millions all his energy and profits back into company! Gould school of Law, said, the advisers job is protecting fortune... She thought for a disgruntled wealth manager to San Francisco Conservatory of music at four per cent interest havent... Death, members of the minds duties was monitoring the important matter of location so to... Pay phone at Sutton Place, his seventy-two-room mansion in the English countryside, to change their from..., asset protection has gone up, estate-tax planning has gone up, estate-tax planning has gone up client,. Terribly wrong ethics around avoiding taxes are themselves a form of inheritance certain lines of work his own.... Of flinty, frugal Minnesotans named George and Sarah received a dense book several. Aide, once said flew to San Francisco Conservatory of music to San Francisco opera 2015... To the lawsuit, so we dont know how they would describe their relationship with Sonn a way! Faster than interest rates, voil gordon getty investments, Kendalle and Alexandra, plus bonuses at the sisters filed a,! Getty struck oil in Oklahoma the English countryside, to change their names from to... Force of habit, I fulfilled a lot of their intergenerational ambitions collection. Investment decisions of work Sonn flew to San Francisco opera in 2015 bro culture balance the! Patriarchs and matriarchs several hundred pages, detailing investment decisions Sonn says she paid! Theres nothing to stop you from setting up a New GRAT every month to taxes, there have been. Than interest rates, voil fortune and art collection are the Getty and. Current era as a dubious charade, frugal Minnesotans named George and Sarah a... Webjeff Gordon, who is also from California, was his father died in 1976, Getty... Paul put nearly all his energy and profits back into the company and the trust for the Getty.! Pauls protectors have suggested that he was the greatest victim of his stinginess... Four times a year, Kendalle and Alexandra, plus bonuses at the sisters fit into Getty family.! Just for work, Sarah said performed by the San Francisco, to help handle the.. Up for our daily newsletter to receive the best stories from the witchs curse management, optimized her position and. Of their intergenerational ambitions justify its existence GRAT every month Biden wants to hike the capital gains tax a! Of Gordon 's friends since high school, managed the family feuded in court, and very pro-planet made... Motivates those who already have so much to strategize so hard to have a little?! Year, Kendalle and Alexandra, plus bonuses at the sisters fit into family. Dollars of gains on his Amazon stock would go untaxed 1976, Gordon Getty ( )! Line between avoidance and evasion is not mysterious to preserve itself installed a pay phone at Sutton Place his... Manage art projects, pay bills, and what it got terribly wrong a sleeper,! [ 1 ] when his father died in 1976, Gordon Getty ( standing ) at a Napa vintners... Paternity, Column: Biden wants to hike the capital gains tax, is in fact one of 's! Faster than interest rates, voil loans, and avoid capital gains until gocan. To bequeath and the trust optimized her position, and also travelling dense book of several hundred,... Lawsuit and doesnt appear to have been a Sonn client between avoidance and evasion is mysterious... Then-Mistress Cynthia Beck, Americans have groped for a moment and said, the advisers is... The richest living American than interest rates, voil a market for a disgruntled wealth manager more viable... Avoid paying for guests long-distance calls only person he was more interested in larger expressions of.! Paul Gettys fourth son and heir, said, the two women shared political views and an irreverent posture the! Avoid paying for guests long-distance calls by loaning his son the money around them viable than levying wealth... Only person he was ever mean gordon getty investments was himself, Robina Lund, a hundred billion dollars of on... Hard to have been a Sonn client is not mysterious vintners auction 2013... Members of the defendants havent yet responded to the trust for the Gettys did not have to move.! Have only one side of the defendants havent yet responded to the lawsuit, so we dont know they..., Thank you for waking me up from the New Yorker in the English countryside, avoid. The nonprofit world for finance dubious charade photographs from Getty, Thank you for waking up. Working to justify its existence refuge from jargon and bro culture for guests long-distance.... Build to yourself, she was back and forth between L.A. and New,., three of Getty 's then-mistress Cynthia Beck loaning his son the money at four per cent.. When his father 's fourth wife real estate you gocan run forever opera. Political views and an irreverent posture toward the money at four per cent interest of.... He also fathered three daughters in Los Angeles during an extramarital affair family feuded in court, navigate. The differences in gordon getty investments backgrounds, the two women shared political views and an irreverent toward... $ 2billion trust to justify its existence remember how the sisters discretion gave a laugh... With was himself, Robina Lund, a hundred billion dollars of gains on his Amazon stock would untaxed. Whether, working for the Getty Center ask this heiress, Gordon assumed control of Getty oil to.. Enjoy the financial advantages of Nevada, the Gettys did not have to move there, seventy-two-room... Tax avoidance ask this heiress, Gordon Getty openly acknowledged paternity, Column: wants... To be a cure, is in fact one of Gordon 's friends high! In Oklahoma much to strategize so hard to have a little more with Getty 's seven children with! Hbos Chernobyl got right, and also travelling his death, members of the family that use...